Home » Featured, Headline

Who Wants to Take the 5th?

Don Rose 3 February 2009 10 Comments

The 5th is the second toughest machine-controlled Democratic congressional district in Chicago. It differs slightly from the conservative, Lipinski-locked 3rd CD by virtue of having a handful of sometimes independent and liberal lakefront precincts, which casts about 18 percent of the vote.

A special primary election will be held here March 3 to replace Rahm Emanuel, who has gone to White House heaven–a different place from his predecessors, Dan Rostenkowski and Rod Blagojevich.

The district’s power emanates from the most odiously connected elements of the Machine, lodged in the western wards and suburbs, where the line between crime and politics is often diffuse.

The big boss is State Sen. Jim DeLeo, indicted in the “Greylord” court bribery scandal, who got a hung jury in his trial then pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge to preserve his legislative post.

Then comes 36th Ward alderman/committeeman William J.P. Banks, whose opponents frequently accused him of ties to the old First Ward, when that term was a euphemism. He chairs the powerful City Council Zoning Committee.

William’s brother, Sam Banks, often represents mobsters as a defense lawyer. Sam’s name popped up in the recent “Family Secrets” trial as a go-between or bagman alleged to have made a payoff to crooked cops. Of course, no one ever saw any money change hands.

Sam’s son James is one of our town’s most successful zoning lawyers, whose triumphs may be due in part to practicing his craft before his Uncle Bill’s committee.

Another fortunate zoning lawyer is candidate John “All in the Family” Fritchey, Sam’s son-in-law, who just happens to have the support of most of the west-end committeemen-though he shudders at the thought of being known as the Machine Candidate. After all, in his other role, as state representative in the seat once held by Blagojevich, he often votes with the liberals.

“All in the Family” Fritchey, who also is 32nd Ward committeeman, is one of three leading candidates, along with State Rep. Sara Feigenholtz. A sliver of her legislative district is in the 5th CD. She is permitted to vote a liberal/feminist line in accord with her constituency, but otherwise requires surgical removal from House Speaker Mike Madigan-whose Chicago firm, surprise, practices zoning law.

Feigenholtz doled out lots of cash to Blagojevich before voting to impeach him–and manages to disappear when critical reform votes come up, such as the bill to permit recall of errant public officials. (“Reformer” Fritchey voted outright against the bill.) Feigenholtz, however, will gain a gender vote throughout the district-perhaps as much as 25 percent, which could win in this divided field.

The third leading candidate is County Commissioner Mike Quigley, known citywide as a genuine reformer on the County Board. His campaign seems to be based on the fact that he is more against County Board President Todd Stroger than anyone on the planet-or at least any of the 14 candidates running. (Petition challenges may soon narrow the field.)

He would be a very good choice except for two factors:

1) We really need to keep him on the County Board; and

2) There is a truly remarkable progressive running with a life-long record of writings and actual deeds that put him head and shoulders above all the rest-though he admittedly is fighting an uphill battle in this situation.

But first a word about the others: Two of them are legacy candidates, hoping to garner votes because their names are Capparelli–the same as 41st Ward Committeeman Ralph–and Annunzio–the same as the Mob-backed congressman who once represented part of this district. There is Pete Dagher, a former Clinton official who threatens to become a perennial, and a woman pilot named Jan Donatelli who may be there to split the Feigenholtz vote.

There are a couple of doctors: Victor Forys and Paul Bryer, a psychiatrist, Carlos Monteagudo, and realtor Paul Thompson, about whose records little is known, but all acquitted themselves honorably at a recent forum in Lincoln Park.

We know a lot about 40th Ward alderman/committeeman Pat O’Connor, who sought Richard M. Daley’s endorsement, which never happened. We know his wife is in the real estate business and he arranges zoning in the ward. Their two interests magically come together as one. He may be laughed off the ballot when the newspapers rerun his adventures.

There also is a smart and capable University of Chicago economist running with an armload of credentials in public policy and journalism. Charlie Wheelan calls himself a “centrist” Democrat whose writings preach the free-market gospel and globalism. Ooops!

Though we don’t “endorse” at the Observer, as a resident of the district, my vote will go to Tom Geoghegan, a labor lawyer and author of several important books. He gets things done while others hypothesize. (He is endorsed by The Nation magazine.) He is the law partner of former Alderman Leon M. Despres, a father of progressive reform in Chicago, which speaks volumes in itself.

Recently Geoghegan (pronounced gae-gun) won a huge class-action suit against Advocate Health Care that will, according to the Sun-Times, “result in free or reduced-price care for low income patients at Advocate hospitals.”

That was typical of Geoghegan’s successful fight for poor and working people–translating the smart ideas of his books into tangible action. His record and economic ideas might just resonate in the working-class western end of the district.

But then, he may be overqualified for Congress.

10 Comments »

  • Yellow Dog Democrat said:

    === Feigenholtz doled out lots of cash to Blagojevich before voting to impeach him ===

    Kind of stretches the definition of ‘before’; I looked and Feigenholtz hasn’t given Rod a dime for nearly three years.

    === County Commissioner Mike Quigley, known citywide as a genuine reformer on the County Board. His campaign seems to be based on the fact that he is more against County Board President Todd Stroger than anyone on the planet ===

    As long as you ignore Quigley’s endorsement of Stroger, and the fact that he was a key County Board ally during the first several months of the Stroger Presidency.

    I haven’t met Geoghegan, but he sounds like an interesting chap, and any Congressional candidate who openly supports legalizing gay marriage is certainly courageous and worth a look. But do you think a Democrat who is actively campaigning to legalize gay marriage can win a Congressional district which – as you describe it – only contains a handful of lakefront precincts?

  • Joe Lake said:

    Who Wants to Take the 5th? …

    John Kass on WTTW with John Callaway Jan. 30, 2009 and posted on the Chicago Daily Observer Feb. 2, 2009–a classic interview about ‘The Chicago Way,’ ‘The Chicago Machine’ and The Illinois Combine.’
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Il5thCD/message/219

    From Don Rose, Feb. 3, 2009, “All in the Family’ [John] Fritchey, who is also 32nd Ward committeeman, is one of the three leading candidates …”

    Joe Lake, Bucktown

  • Joe Lake said:

    Fixed Link for John Kass Interview Above:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/IL5thCD/message/219

    Joe Lake, Bucktown

  • Alex said:

    Quigley ran against Jr. Stroger in the last election but dropped out and supported Forrest Claypool….the other main reformer amongst the commissioners.

  • Mansion said:

    State Representative John Fritchy is a zoning lawyer first. State Rep second. His father in law is the zoning chair of Chicago zoning committee and you do not think he slides stuff through?

    Google in Castle and Fritchey and see what you get. Probably the shadiest deal known to residents in Independence Park and Chicago. A state rep/zoning lawyer working for a shady rapper who got a nice zoning deal on a nice little neighborhood block.

    IF you want more of the same suspect dealings in Congress,I suggest you vote for State Representative John Fritchey.

  • Dan Kelley said:

    When Blagojevich first set his sights on campaigning for Congress, Fritchey was the beneficiary of a deal between the 33rd and 36th Ward Democratic Organizations that resulted in the precinct captains pushing Rod for Congressman and Fritchey for State Representative as Blagojevich’s replacement in Springfield. Both men won in the primary and the general election in 1996.

    Some people have suggested that former US Representative Dan Rostenkowski (D-5th) was defeated by the unknown Republican candidate, Michael Patrick Flanagan, in 1994 because certain key Democratic committeeman opted to soft peddle Rosty during the general election. Rosty was making only his second run in the 5th District after the districts had been remapped and portions of the former 8th and 11th Districts were merged together. Rosty had also been named in a scandal that subsequently sent him to prison. In certain precincts in the 5th District, there were voters who were less than pleased to have a brand new congressman whose name was constantly in the press for the wrong reasons. Some observers think that Blagojevich’s father-in-law, Dick Mell, helped push Rostenkowski into retirement in 1994 in order to promote Blagojevich to Congress in 1996.

  • Charlotte Newfeld said:

    Re Tom Geoghegan and the 5th. Every political junky knows Campaign Lit and requests for money must carry a Union \"Bug\". For a Labor Lawyer it is even more important. The Bug was no where on the Leon Despres endorsement and fund request piece received Feb 4. What say you?

  • mansion said:

    Beware of John fritchey.
    This guy is not good for illinois at all.
    we wonder how he gets away with the same thing that Blago did not.

  • Julie Sweet said:

    Hi Charlotte -

    Glad to hear you received the letter announcing Leon Despres\’ endorsement of Tom Geoghegan. All of Tom\’s printed materials come from either a local union shop or they are printed in house.

    Julie Sweet
    Tom Geoghegan for Congress

  • David Anderson said:

    In this environment of corruption, do you think that it is a lock that Republicans cannot make any progress in this district?? There is so much corruption and dishonesty among all these Democrats…people are sick of it!

    http://WWW.DRDAVEFORCONGRESS.COM!!!

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.