Home » Featured, Headline

Controversy and Reactions: Obama, Gates, U of I, Pat Quinn

Phil Krone 30 July 2009 10 Comments

The President is having Professor Henry Louis Gates, Jr., generally
known as ‘Skip’, and the policeman who arrested him over for a beer
tomorrow at the White House in an appropriate attempt to reconcile the
unfortunate incident that occurred last week at Dr. Gate’s home.

I have only met Skip Gates once.  It was in either 1996 or 1997 at a
previous home he owned.  I was the guest of my friend Tom Ashbrook, at
the time a Neiman fellow.  Mary Schmich of the Chicago Tribune was also
there.  In fact Skip was hosting all the Neiman Fellows and I can tell
you in addition to all his academic credentials, he is a first class
barman, and proud of it.  He’s also a brilliant conversationalist and
not excessively politically correct.  He is a fun guy (and I don’t mean
a mushroom) as well as being a brilliant scholar.  What happened at his
house when he returned from an exhausting trip to China was
unfortunate.  But it certainly demonstrates the ying and yang of being
policed and being protected.  If he hadn’t been there and it had been
somebody else actually breaking in, even in broad daylight, he would
have been grateful that the police arrived.

In all of this discussion one person has been left out and should also
be invited to the party and that is Lucia Whalen, the lady who called in
the complaint at the request of another observer.  If she hasn’t been,
it would be worthwhile to have another party, as these problems are not
going to be resolved in just an hour or two.  An idea is germinating in
my mind that portends a new career for Professor Gates, one which would
put him in the path of Robert Kennedy and Hillary Clinton, and perhaps
replace a man now entitled to a full pension.  Enough clues.  More later.

The U of I Trustees and Governor Quinn

The present controversy over favoritism at the University of Illinois
has virtually scratched the surface.  I am sure that the commission
investigating these issues, Abner Mikva, will not allow it to turn into
either a whitewash or a witchhunt.  If Walter Cronkite was the most
trusted man in America, Abner Mikva might well be among the most
trusted citizens in Illinois, along with people of the caliber of Lois
Wille, Judge George Leighton and Dawn Clark Netsch.

In achieving his goal of straightening out the admission system at our
great land grant university, one of the finest in the nation, it might
well call for new leadership.  I happen to know several of the
trustees.  One who is taking inordinate heat is the new Chair, Niranjan
Shah. He has never been a client of mine, but I have known him since
1992.  There is no doubt that he has had tens of millions in government
contracts for his engineering firm, but I’ve never heard that his
firm has charged for work not done, or ever performed in a shoddy
manner.  Public records show that he has been a very generous
contributor, but there is no correlation between the size of his
contracts and the size of his contributions, especially when spread out
over a period of twenty years.  And he does it openly.  I’ve never heard
that he has put pressure to get contracts.  He just doesn’t want to be
discriminated against which should be entirely understandable.  He
doesn’t pay to play.  He contributes so that he’ll be able to have a
chance to play fairly.

I am sure that being Chairman of the U of Trustees has been his proudest
achievement and I fell badly that he, in his own words, used poor
judgment, albeit in literally a handful of cases, including once for his
future son in law, who thank goodness was first in his class at Oxford
(the university in the United Kingdom, not the institution in Wisconsin).

It may be necessary, not just for public relations, but because of his
own personal health for him to resign, but he should be respected for
his many contributions to promoting excellence at the U of I.

Like Senator Burris, Governor Quinn is serving in his office because of
the Blagojevich (mainly self inflicted) tragedy.  Like Burris, who
incidentally was a prominent state wide elected official more than ten
years  before Blagojevich was elected to any office, Quinn now has the
opportunity to dedicate the rest of  this term, seventeen full months,
to dealing with extremely critical state problems.  I hope he does not
seek election, not just because I intend to support another person, but
because he should attempt to leave a legacy of trust and
accomplishment unburdened by the need to campaign and raise funds
risking defeat both in the primary and the general election; and more
importantly wasting the opportunity he has to make a lasting
contribution to the betterment of our state.

Dealing with the University of Illinois and the state budget are
tremendous tasks.  The latter will not be solved in the next seventeen
months, but Quinn’s lasting achievement in addition to his conscientious
and apolitical, albeit symbolic, commitment to literally attending the
funeral of every Illinoisan killed in action in Iraq or Afghanistan,
will be reforming the governance of the University of Illinois.

Senator Burris should have announced he wasn’t running for election (not
re-election) to the U.S. Senate when he accepted the tainted
appointment.  Governor Quinn should have done the same and he still has
time — maybe at ‘Governors’ Day at the State Fair later in August.

For Quinn, not running would not be a sign of weakness, but a sign of
strength.  I’ve known him since 1973 and I sincerely hope he doesn’t not
squander this limited accidental opportunity to make an enormous
contribution to our state by devoting the next seventeen months to
public service free from the need of campaigning for election.


Phil Krone is a regular columnist for the Chicago Daily Observer

Image Alma Mater, Lorado Taft, Altgeld Hall, University of Illinois


  • Dan Kelley said:

    The legislative scholarship program that permits every member of the Illinois General Assembly to award free passes to the University of Illinois needs to be examined also.

  • PhilKrone said:

    For obvious ethical reasons, I feel obligated to report that I am now professionally (strategic public relations) advising Mr. Shah. However, through an unbelievable but verificable set of coincidences this arrangement was made after I submitted this column, but before it was published. Indeed, after agreeing to advise Mr. Shah, I asked the yet unpublished article be cancelled but my request was not read in time.

    I have great respect for Chairman Mikva and Chairman Shah. I hope there is an appropriate resolution to these problems, but I wouldn’t be involved with Niranjan Shah if I din’t believe him to be a man of integrity, intelligence and ability. The reason I recommended that he resign from this unpaid position is because his nature is not to be confrontational. But I will support him in whatever course he chooses to take.

  • A UIS grad said:

    Shah should be the first person to go, followed by ANYONE Blago appointed. What you HAVEN’T heard about him could fill volumes. Are you not aware of his complicated financial relationship with Blago & other Dem. pols? PLEASE! And he “asked” the U of I to indulge him & sponsor his soon-to-be son-in-law (they created a job for him so he could come to the US). WASTE OF MONEY, unseemly and HORRIBLE abuse of power. Again, ANYONE Blago put on the U of I board should be gone. Time to clean house–time to take the politics out of education (but that’ll take a REALLY LARGE broom).

  • Phil Krone said:

    Remembering that I wrote this article prior to being retained as an advisor, not the advisor, to Mr. Shah, I am answering this independently, but re-announcing my now obvious conflict.

    First of all, Shah should not go simply because he was appointed by former Governor Blagojevich. There are many people appointed by Blagojevich who are qualified and honorable. I do not believe in guilt by association.

    Also, there is nothing complicated about Shah’s relationship with any politicans, Republican as well as Democratic. He has contributed to many campoaigns (a matter of public record), most of whom have been excellent public officials. Frankly, most firms who compete for legitimate government business, contribute to campaigns; but I don’t believe there is a quid pro quo, I am not naive, however, and I would assume that those firms which are qualified have a better chance of geting a share of government work at competitive prices if they have contributed. But it is not like he has a monopoly in providing professional services. And he himself is a licensed award winning engineer with a college degree in engineering. Not too shabby.

    Mr. Shah has apologized for intervening on behalf of his future son in law, frankly, unnecessarily I believe. His son in law was first in his class at Oxford (United Kingdom), and while I don’t know for sure, and it it is not my place to ask, I would think the reason he asked to have his prospective son in law get a job at the U of I for which he was qualified was to be able to legitimately speed up the visa process.

    He is not an illegal alien, and we, save for the native Americans on this continent before 1492, are indeed a nation of immigrants. You might say in this age of globalization that Shah’s son in law’s coming to the U.S. was our gain and Europe’s loss. In fact Shah himself came to the U.S. in 1970 from India. I am happy that there are so many immigrants from Asia now in the U.S. enriching and diversifying our culture.

    The son in law, by the way, no longer works for the U of I and his compensation is much greater than that which he received at the U o I.

    All of the charges I’m answering are coming from an anoymous source. I support Narinja Shah until someone proves that he was paid for work he did not do, or that the work he did was not of high quality. I have never heard either.

    As shoddy, mean spirited and vituperative these remarks are, I will continue to respond to them, which by the way is not part of my agreement with Shah, and reflects my opinion only. He is not advising or censoring me on my responses.

    Shah does not have the kind of personality that lend himself to responding to these kinds of charges. Damn, I wish he had a few ounces of Sarah Palin in him.

  • U Of I Grad said:

    Shah’s engineering company, Globetrotters, was repremanded By the Il DOT for overbilling.

  • Lets say I have $5 million dollars to spend on foreign exchange, which 4 currencies should I buy out of these: | Foreign Exchange Quotes (author) said:

    […] Controversy and Reactions: Obama, Gates, U of I, Pat Quinn … […]

  • Phil Krone said:

    I would respectfully ask the poster of the next to last comment to provide, anonymously if he/she wishes, evidence of such a reprimand, and the resolution of it. It should be easy to offer the proof if there is any. And there could be an explanation fo it, especially if it is de minimis. As someone said, I would like to have the pennies which AT&T or Exxon Mobil round off.

    And I would like the poster of the last comment to please explain it to me. I apologize for being so obtuse. I truly enjoy the dialogue this site offers, even from the anonymous participants.

  • Niranjan Shah- Renowned Entrepreneur and Philanthropist – That Thing (author) said:

    […] good facilities in his hometown. So, it is important to state that one should try his best to become a good source of help for others. If one cannot do so, it could create big troubles in his life, and he will find himself a total […]

  • The Corporate Life of Niranjan Shah (The Mushroom Shop) (author) said:

    […] Indiana, and Wisconsin. To add on to his engineering credentials, Niranjan Shah enrolled at the Harvard Business School, where he pursued a management training program. He is also a part of the American Society of Civil […]

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.